Discover the Top 12 Dining Gems: A Guide to the Best Restaurants in Saint Michaels, Maryland

Saint Michaels, Maryland, is a picturesque town located on the Chesapeake Bay and is home to some of the best seafood restaurants in the entire region.

With its charming streets lined with historic homes and boutiques, Saint Michaels is a popular destination for tourists seeking some of the best culinary delights the area has to offer.

If you’re planning a visit to this beautiful town, be sure to check out the top 12 best restaurants in Saint Michaels, where you can indulge in delicious seafood, fine dining, and casual comfort food, all freshly prepared by some of the best chefs in the area.

From waterfront locations to cozy farm-to-table settings, each restaurant on this list offers a unique dining experience that you won’t want to miss.

Now, come along and discover the best places to eat in Saint Michaels, Maryland.

12 Best Restaurants In Saint Michaels Maryland

From cozy coffee shops to elegant waterfront dining, there’s something for every palate. Here are the 12 best restaurants in Saint Michaels, Maryland that you absolutely must try:

1. Stars Restaurant at the Inn at Perry Cabin

Overview: Stars is an upscale dining venue within the luxurious Inn at Perry Cabin, offering a refined dining experience that embodies elegance and sophistication.

Location: Nestled on the banks of the Miles River, the restaurant offers stunning views that elevate the dining experience.

Cuisine: Stars celebrates the Eastern Shore’s seasonal bounties, crafting dishes using fresh, locally sourced ingredients that offer a gastronomic journey through Maryland’s culinary landscape.

Special Menu: The Captain’s Menu, available every Friday and Saturday, is a tribute to the local Watermen. This menu features the freshest seafood, showcasing the region’s rich aquatic offerings.

Seafood Specialities: As a premier seafood restaurant, Stars offers a variety of seafood options, providing a taste of the ocean’s finest offerings.

Dining Experience: With its waterside views, elegant decor, and meticulous service, Stars provides a memorable dining experience that transcends the ordinary.

Service: The staff are trained to provide exceptional service, ensuring guests’ needs are met promptly and courteously.

Reservation: Given its popularity, making a reservation in advance is advisable to secure a table at your preferred time.

Dress Code: The dress code is smart casual, reflecting the restaurant’s sophisticated ambiance.

Reviews: Stars has garnered positive reviews for its excellent food, service, and ambiance, making it a top choice for fine dining in Saint Michaels.

2. Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar

Overview: Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar is a popular spot in Saint Michaels, renowned for its delicious pizzas and extensive wine list.

Location: Conveniently located in the heart of Saint Michaels, it’s an ideal stop for a casual meal while exploring the town.

Cuisine: While pizza is their specialty, they also offer a variety of other Italian dishes that cater to different tastes.

Pizza Varieties: Their pizza menu is diverse, featuring both classic favorites and unique creations that pizza lovers will appreciate.

Wine Selection: They offer a vast selection of wines, ensuring there’s a perfect pairing for every pizza and palate.

Atmosphere: The relaxed and cozy atmosphere is perfect for a laid-back meal or a casual gathering with friends.

Service: The friendly and knowledgeable staff can guide you through the menu and make recommendations based on your preferences.

Reservation: Although they accept reservations, walk-ins are also welcome, making it a flexible option for diners.

Dress Code: The dress code is casual, befitting the relaxed vibe of the pizzeria.

Reviews: It consistently receives high ratings from customers, demonstrating its quality and popularity among locals and visitors alike.

3. The Crab Claw Restaurant

Overview: The Crab Claw Restaurant is a landmark in Saint Michaels, renowned for serving seafood lovers for decades.

Location: Its prime location near the Maritime Museum provides beautiful waterfront views that enhance the dining experience.

Cuisine: They specialize in fresh, local seafood, with crab dishes being their standout offerings.

Unique Feature: The restaurant offers the unique experience of watching the operation of one of the oldest crab picking houses in the world.

Seafood Variety: Apart from crabs, they serve a wide range of other seafood options, ensuring there’s something for every seafood lover.

Atmosphere: The casual atmosphere and waterfront location make it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal while taking in the scenic views.

Service: The staff are known for their warm hospitality and quick service, contributing to a pleasant dining experience.

Reservation: Given its popularity, it’s recommended to make a reservation during peak hours.

Dress Code: Casual attire is acceptable here, reflecting the laid-back vibe of the restaurant.

Reviews: With numerous positive reviews, it’s clear that their fresh seafood and great location have endeared them to many patrons.

4. Bistro St. Michaels

Overview: Bistro St. Michaels is a fine dining venue that combines classic and modern cuisine to offer a unique gastronomic experience.

Location: Ideally located on Talbot Street, it’s easily accessible and right in the heart of St. Michaels.

Cuisine: The menu changes frequently to incorporate the freshest seasonal ingredients, resulting in dishes that are both innovative and delicious.

Special Feature: The bistro stands out for its creative blend of traditional and contemporary flavors, which results in truly unique dishes that delight the palate.

Atmosphere: The stylish decor and intimate setting make it an ideal choice for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.

Service: The professional and attentive staff ensure a pleasant dining experience by catering to guests’ needs promptly and courteously.

Reservation: Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends and holidays, to avoid disappointment.

Dress Code: Smart casual attire is encouraged, in keeping with the bistro’s elegant ambiance.

Reviews: It has received high praise for its innovative menu and elegant atmosphere, making it a top choice for fine dining in Saint Michaels.

5. Foxy’s Harbor Grille

Overview: Foxy’s Harbor Grille is a well-loved destination in Saint Michaels, renowned for its seafood dishes and casual, beachy atmosphere.

Location: Situated near the harbor, diners can enjoy beautiful water views, adding to the overall dining experience.

Cuisine: The menu is a seafood lover’s delight featuring an array of options such as crab cakes, shrimp, and fish prepared in various styles. Non-seafood options are also available.

Atmosphere: The laid-back, beach shack style ambiance makes it a perfect place to relax and enjoy a meal after a day of sightseeing or boating.

Service: Foxy’s is known for its friendly staff who are attentive and make sure guests have a pleasant dining experience.

Outdoor Seating: The restaurant features outdoor seating where guests can enjoy their meal while taking in the beautiful harbor views.

Entertainment: Foxy’s hosts live music events on certain days, enhancing the lively, fun-filled atmosphere.

Reviews: Guests often praise the restaurant’s tasty food, excellent location, and vibrant atmosphere.

6. Blue Crab Coffee Co.

Overview: Blue Crab Coffee Co. is a quaint coffee shop that serves up a variety of hot and cold beverages along with light fare.

Location: Its central location in Saint Michaels makes it a convenient stop for a coffee break during your town visit.

Menu: The menu includes a wide range of coffee drinks from classic espressos to flavored lattes, teas, and an assortment of pastries and sandwiches.

Atmosphere: With a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere, it’s an ideal place to unwind with a good book or catch up with friends over coffee.

Service: Baristas here are friendly and skilled, ensuring each drink is made to perfection.

Takeout Options: For those in a hurry, they offer takeout options so you can enjoy your coffee on the go.

Reviews: It’s highly rated for its quality coffee, friendly customer service, and cozy atmosphere.

7. Gina’s Café

Overview: Gina’s Café is a charming, family-run eatery offering a variety of home-cooked meals.

Location: It’s conveniently nestled in downtown Saint Michaels, making it easily accessible.

Cuisine: The menu is diverse, featuring a mix of American favorites and international dishes, ensuring there’s something for every palate.

Atmosphere: The café exudes a warm and inviting vibe, with its cozy interiors making you feel at home instantly.

Service: The staff at Gina’s are known for their friendliness and prompt service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

Outdoor Seating: When weather permits, the café offers outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy their meal in the open air.

Reviews: Customers frequently compliment the café’s tasty food, homely atmosphere, and excellent service.

8. Carpenter Street Saloon

Overview: Carpenter Street Saloon is a local favorite, serving as both a bar and restaurant.

Location: As the name suggests, it’s located on Carpenter Street, right in the heart of the town.

Menu: They offer a variety of drinks from beers to cocktails, and a food menu featuring pub-style fare like burgers and fries.

Atmosphere: The saloon has a lively, rustic atmosphere, often hosting local events and live music, making it a fun spot for a night out.

Service: The staff are friendly and efficient, ensuring guests are well taken care of.

Entertainment: Live music or other entertainment is often available, adding to the lively atmosphere of the saloon.

Reviews: It’s well-rated for its fun atmosphere, good selection of drinks, and hearty food.

9. Two If By Sea Restaurant

Overview: This is a fine dining restaurant that offers an intimate and relaxed dining experience.

Location: It’s situated a bit off the beaten path, providing a quiet and peaceful dining environment away from the hustle and bustle.

Cuisine: The menu features an array of seafood dishes, complemented by steak, chicken, and vegetarian options. The food is thoughtfully prepared and beautifully presented.

Atmosphere: The restaurant offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere, with tastefully done interiors that add to the charm.

Service: The staff are attentive and professional, ensuring guests have a memorable dining experience.

Reservation: Given the restaurant’s popularity, making a reservation is recommended to secure your preferred dining time.

Reviews: Two If By Sea Restaurant has received positive reviews for its delicious food, elegant setting, and outstanding service.

10. Theo’s Steaks, Sides & Spirits

Overview: Theo’s is a casual yet sophisticated steakhouse known for its quality steaks and vibrant atmosphere.

Location: Conveniently located in the heart of St. Michaels, it’s easily accessible to both locals and tourists.

Cuisine: As the name suggests, the menu primarily features an array of hand-carved steaks, but also includes local seafood, upscale appetizers, and classic American dishes.

Ambiance: The interior is sleek and traditional, providing a comfortable and inviting dining atmosphere.

Service: Known for their attentive and friendly service, the staff at Theo’s go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience.

Drinks: They offer a variety of spirits, including a good selection of wines that pair well with their meals.

Reservation: Given its popularity, it’s advisable to make a reservation to secure a table.

Hours: It’s important to check the working hours before planning your visit as they may vary.

Reviews: Theo’s has received rave reviews for its delicious food, great ambiance, and excellent service.

Website: For more information about their menu and any special events, you can visit their official website.

11. Town Dock Food & Spirits

Overview: Town Dock Food & Spirits is a popular spot known for its diverse menu and welcoming atmosphere.

Location: It’s situated near the water, offering beautiful views to its guests.

Cuisine: The cuisine is varied, featuring a mix of seafood, meat, and vegetarian dishes.

Atmosphere: The restaurant has a casual, relaxed vibe, making it a great place to unwind with good food and drinks.

Service: The staff are friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

Drinks: In addition to their food menu, they offer a range of spirits and cocktails.

Outdoor Seating: When the weather permits, outdoor seating is available, allowing guests to dine while enjoying the view.

Reservation: Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

Reviews: It has garnered positive reviews for its tasty food, friendly service, and lovely location.

Hours: Be sure to check their operating hours before planning your visit.

12. Limoncello Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar

Overview: Limoncello is an Italian restaurant known for its authentic cuisine and extensive wine list.

Location: Its location in downtown Saint Michaels makes it a convenient dining option for locals and tourists alike.

Cuisine: The menu boasts a wide range of Italian classics, from pasta and risotto to various meat and seafood dishes.

Atmosphere: The restaurant exudes a warm and cozy atmosphere, reminiscent of a traditional Italian trattoria.

Service: Staff at Limoncello are known for their hospitality and attentiveness, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Wine Selection: As a wine bar, they offer an impressive selection of Italian and international wines.

Reservation: Given its popularity, making a reservation is recommended to avoid disappointment.

Reviews: It’s highly rated for its authentic Italian dishes, excellent wine selection, and warm ambiance.

Hours: Checking the restaurant’s operating hours before planning your visit is advisable.

Conclusion

From the sophisticated ambiance and top-notch steaks at Theo’s Steaks, Sides & Spirits, to the relaxing waterfront setting and diverse menu at Town Dock Food & Spirits, there’s something for everyone.

For those craving Italian cuisine, Limoncello Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar stands out with its authentic dishes and extensive wine list. Casual eateries like Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar and Foxy’s Harbor Grille offer laid-back environments perfect for a leisurely meal, while places like Blue Crab Coffee Co. serve as cozy spots for a coffee break.

Seafood lovers will find plenty to enjoy at establishments like The Crab Claw Restaurant and Two If By Sea Restaurant, which showcase the region’s rich aquatic offerings.

Whether you’re seeking an upscale dining experience, a casual meal, or anything in between, Saint Michaels, Maryland has a restaurant that will satisfy your culinary desires. Each establishment not only provides delicious food but also contributes to the overall charm and appeal of this historic waterfront town.

No visit to Saint Michaels would be complete without exploring its diverse and delightful culinary landscape.